Sunday, August 12, 2007

Re: Religion. Beneficial?

Duration: 1100 seconds
Upload Time: 07-01-18 17:03:19
User: websnarf
:::: Favorites
Description:

Religion as a force for good? Update: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aSEwc302gSs

Comments
websnarf ::: Favorites
As I explained in my video about "How I became an Atheist", the existence of a book does not imply that its contents are sound. Not surprisingly this is a *NEW* book, that has not yet been definitively debunked, besides the two minute job I just did.
07-01-20 02:00:10
_____________________________________________________
Prepoceros ::: Favorites
How does repeating a book's conclusions debunk it? Those differences are hardly "borderline noise": $88 in $642 (assuming secular people mostly give to secular causes) is 14%. I know that lots of books are crap. I'm willing to consider this one, as I said, because I've heard people whose opinions I trust report on it without disdain. Perhaps it will eventually be debunked, but so far I've seen nothing of the sort.
07-01-20 10:23:28
_____________________________________________________
Prepoceros ::: Favorites
You are an atheist, BTW.
07-01-20 10:28:51
_____________________________________________________
Prepoceros ::: Favorites
(I should mention that I'm not championing this book unequivocally -- it's not a pet of mine -- but I didn't want to see a comment like the one you made cheered loudly without even a whimper of protest.)
07-01-20 10:36:49
_____________________________________________________
websnarf ::: Favorites
Ok, criticism accepted. Thus I should amend my comment to: "The Xians *do* bandy about figures, when they exist convenient to their case -- but strangely only those numbers not yet vetted through any process of serious scientific scrutiny".
07-01-20 15:00:57
_____________________________________________________
freetaught ::: Favorites
Websnarf- You are obviously a man who speaks passionatly about your beliefs,and It is my opinion that what you believe comes from good intention.I look forward to watching some of your old videos and learning more about you,at that time I hope that we will be able to discuss some of your views!Until then be good to yourself!
07-01-23 22:54:08
_____________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
Rex20171 ::: Favorites
Your way of thinking when it comes to religion is like saying "cars put people in boxes." How would you react if I proved to you that God is real?
07-01-27 22:01:07
_____________________________________________________
loneflower8 ::: Favorites
If someone proved God to be real I would acknowledge its existence but I wouldn't really care whether I followed it or obeyed it.
07-01-27 23:42:14
_____________________________________________________
abortedsoul ::: Favorites
You are very well spoken; please, keep talking.
07-01-27 23:50:12
_____________________________________________________
vegrin ::: Favorites
You the man Websnarf... Just keep the dialougue clear and reasonable like you do now:)
07-02-01 05:59:52
_____________________________________________________

No comments: